The Best Ice Fishing Fish Finders of 2024

0 53

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn more ›

When you’re sitting out in the freezing cold, a good ice fishing fish finder will save you time and energy by quickly and accurately identifying structure and fish below the ice. This means less time drilling holes and more time catching fish. An ice fishing fish finder allows you to target the most productive areas and even watch how fish respond to your lure.

The best units use the most advanced graphing sonar and GPS navigation available. Still, flashers are popular for their accuracy and versatility. To make ice fishing easier and safer, the fish finder is housed in a protective case and powered by a small battery. Load your fish finder in the back of the snow machine, carry it from hole to hole, and even use it on your boat in open water. These are our top picks for the best ice fishing fish finders on the market.

The Best Ice Fishing Fish Finders

Best with GPS: Garmin Echomap Ice Fishing Bundle

Best with GPS

Pros

  • Live view and side view sonar
  • Detailed charts of 18,000 lakes
  • Battery included

Cons

Garmin’s Echomap Ice Fishing Bundle combines the best fish finder and GPS into a convenient carry case with a powerful battery. To find the fish, use the Panoptix LiveScope ForwardVu sonar to search an area up to 100 feet around the hole. Then, switch to LiveScope DownVu to watch the fish respond to your bait.

The Echomap’s GPS utilizes the most detailed Navionics charts to navigate on and off the ice and locate the best fishing areas. And with 18,000 included lakes, odds are pretty good that your home waters—and just about anywhere else you’d want to go—are on there. The high-resolution seven-inch screen is easy to read under any light conditions without draining the battery before the day is over. 

Specs

  • Weight: 16.7 lbs
  • Dimensions: 12.3 × 14.5 × 10.0 inches
  • Screen Size: 7 inches

Best Portable: Vexilar FLX 30BB

Best Portable

Vexilar FLX 30BB is the best portable fish finder.

Pros

  • Power settings to match depth
  • Target identification to ¼ inch
  • Easy to see day or night

Cons

Vexilar ice fishing fish finders are famous for unmatched interference rejection and signal clarity with easy-to-use settings. The brand has released the ultimate sonar flasher for ice fishing. Starting with a bright LED display and 525 segment resolution, the FLX 30BB is easy to read day or night. To produce a detailed reading with accuracy to ¼ inch, the broadband transducer uses frequencies from 160 kHz to 300 kHz. If you’re fishing in a crowd, Vexilar boasts 140 frequency combinations to reduce interference from nearby sonars.

The FLX 30BB display, battery, and transducer travel on a plastic shuttle protected from the elements by a soft case with a clear plastic window over the display. Our favorite features on the Vexilar ice fishing fish finder are the zoom mode for a closeup look at the bottom and the dummy key that sets the flasher on start mode for easy operation.

Specs

  • Weight: 7 lbs 4.5 oz
  • Dimensions:  4.4 x 6 x 2.5 inches
  • Maximum Depth: 300 feet

Best for the Money: Lowrance Hook Reveal 5 Split Shot Ice Pack

Best for the Money

Lowrance Hook Reveal 5 Split Shot Ice Pack is the best fish finder for the money.

Pros

  • Combines DownScan and CHIRP sonar
  • Easy to read display
  • High resolution charts

Cons

The Lowrance Hook 5 Reveal ice fishing fish finder houses an advanced sonar with detailed navigation capabilities in a carry case that can also hold tackle and a battery. Lowrance’s ice fishing fish finder uses Reveal sonar that combines a detailed CHIRP signal to mark fish and a high-resolution DownScan signal for a clearer image of structure.

On the navigation side, coastal and inland charts come standard with the ability to upload more detailed charts. In the bright sun, the SolarMax display cuts the glare for a clear view of the screen. Budget minded anglers looking for an affordable unit will appreciate the Hook 5 Reveal’s advanced fish finder and GPS for under $500.

Specs

  • Weight: 11 lbs
  • Dimensions: 14.5 x 10.2 x 7.5 inches
  • Screen Size: 5 inches

Best for Kayaks: Hawkeye Fishtrax 1c IceShack

Best for Kayaks

Hawkeye FishTrax 1c Ice Fishing Kit

Pros

  • Inexpensive
  • Adaptable
  • Uses AAA batteries

Cons

The Hawkeye Fishtrax 1c is a big surprise in a small package. The three-inch color screen and palm-sized waterproof case look simple, but contained inside is quality tech that makes FishTrax 1c the best fish finder for kayak and ice fishing. The color display and dual frequency transducer produce vivid, detailed images of fish and structure. Switch to flasher mode, and the Hawkeye ice fishing fish finder provides real-time images of action below the ice.

For hard water fishing, carry the Fishtrax 1c in the Ice Shack case, a protective housing with a weighted base to keep the Hawkeye ice fishing fish finder planted and protected. The Fishtrax is also a top-rated fish finder for kayaks. To use the Fishtrax in smaller crafts like that, Hawkeye offers a kayak mount and a transducer arm that attach to a standard gear track. Best of all, FishTrax keeps the Hawkeye light and portable by powering the unit with 4 AAA batteries. 

Specs

  • Weight: 9.4 oz
  • Dimensions: 12 x 10 x 9 inches
  • Screen Size: 3 inches

Best for Boats: Humminbird Ice Helix 9

Best for Boats

Humminbird Ice Helix 9 is the best fish finder for boat and ice fishing.

Pros:

  • Live view, down view, and side view sonar
  • Premium charts and maps
  • Lithium ion battery, carry shuttle and transducer kit included

Cons:

Humminbird pulled out all the stops when designing the Ice Helix 9, easily making it our pick for the best fish finder for boat and ice fishing. To meet the needs of the most demanding hard water anglers, the Ice Helix 9 includes a transducer with MEGA Live, MEGA Down, and MEGA Side imaging capabilities. The bundle also contains a dual spectrum CHIRP ICE transducer, so you can switch over and use the flasher mode for the most accurate real-time depiction of the action under the ice. Using the combination of sonar signals, an angler can search for structure, then hone in on fish and watch them bite. Six settings block interference from nearby fish finders and let you fish in a crowd.

Navigation and mapping are just as important to serious ice anglers. The Helix 9’s Lake Master and Coast Master charts combine with Navionics’ navigation engine to display detailed information about structure and provide accurate navigation on and off the ice.

Not only is Humminbird’s ice fishing fish finder mounted on a convenient shuttle, but it makes a powerful navigation aid and fish finder for boating. Simply install a bracket and compatible transducer in the boat, and the Helix 9 keeps finding fish after the water turns wet. At almost $3,000, the Ice Helix 9 MEGA Live is the most expensive unit in my review, but the accessories and capabilities on the ice and on the boat make it worth the investment.

Specs

  • Screen Size: 9 inches
  • Screen Resolution: 1024H x 600V
  • Power Draw: 2.4 Amps

Best Level of Detail: Garmin LiveScope Plus

Best Level of Detail

Best Ice Fishing Fish Finder

Pros

  • See exactly what’s on the bottom
  • Real-time imaging lets you watch your lure
  • Large, vibrant display

Cons

Garmin’s live scanning sonar has revolutionized the professional bass fishing world. More pros than ever rely on the tech to help them target specific cover and fish in real-time. Because the sonar can view up to 200 feet down and 200 feet away, it’s a natural fit for ice fishing. Set it in a central location and scan the area under the surrounding ice for the next best spot to drill your next hole.

This fish finder bundle comes packaged with Garmin’s Echomap, so you get a unit that’s already preloaded with maps of 18,000 U.S. lakes. Adding in some optional accessories also allows the user to take advantage of Garmin navigation charts and an optional flasher.

Although we suspect most anglers will simply use the incredible detail from the LiveScope to watch their jig in real-time. Garmin packages this finder with a lithium-ion battery that allows you to maximize your time on the water. The only real downside is that this technology is still extremely expensive.

Specs

  • Screen Size: 9 inches
  • Screen Resolution: 800 x 480 pixels
  • Unit Dimensions: 13.8 x 12.2 x 13 inches

Best Budget: Garmin Striker 4 Portable Bundle

Best Budget

Best Ice Fishing Fish Finder

Pros

  • Extremely compact
  • Lightweight
  • Fish finder and flasher capabilities

Cons

  • Screen is very small compared to other units

Finding an affordable ice fishing fish finder is a challenge. The Garmin Striker 4 is one of the few out there that can be found for under $200. This unit does pack quite a few features, including a built-in flasher for jigging. There’s also a GPS unit so you can mark your favorite honey holes. Garmin also included the possibility of upgrading this unit to use their CHIRP sonar technology so you can better chart bottom structure and fish at depth.

We like this unit for anglers on a budget who also want some portability and versatility with their fish finder. You can use this unit on the ice in January and in the kayak during the summer and fall. The downsides to this unit are that the screen is extremely small, and some anglers might not find it adequate. It is also a difficult unit to set up for your initial fishing trip.

Specs

  • Weight: 0.5 pounds
  • Screen Size: 3.5 inches
  • Dimensions: 1.9 x 2.9 inches

Best Display For the Money: Humminbird Ice Helix 5

Best Display for the Money

Best Ice Fishing Fish Finders

Pros

  • Vibrant display
  • Flasher and fish finder combo
  • Affordable

Cons

The displays for today’s modern fish finders keep getting better and better. Humminbird has been making some of the nicest ones in the business for a while now. For the money, the Ice Helix 5 is one of the more affordable five-inch displays out there right now. This unit can be found for under $400 and packs a ton of features, including a flasher and CHIRP sonar that will give you very clear images of fish and bait.

This is another unit that can be easily transferred over to your boat once the ice melts too. Simply hook up a transducer and you are ready to go. With a sonar depth of 400 feet, it can also read deeper than many other units on the market today. The big downside of this unit is that it does not include a GPS features. It is strictly a fish-finding machine.

Specs

  • Screen Size: 5 Inches
  • Screen Resolution: 800H x 480V
  • Power Draw: 615 mA

How We Picked the Best Ice Fishing Fish Finders

To determine the best fish finder for ice fishing, we looked at the quality of construction, accessories, portability, features, and user-friendliness.

  • Construction Quality: Will this unit stand up to hard use on the ice? Will sub-zero temperatures negatively affect the unit in any way? Can it handle bouncing around on the back of a snow machine or being dragged in a sled?
  • Accessories: Fish finders need certain accessories to be effective out on the ice. Does this model have the needed hardware to work on the ice? These include transducer brackets or floats, but other items can prove to be beneficial.
  • Portability: To be useful for ice fishing, a fish finder must be portable. The best models contain all the needed components in an easy-to-carry caddy. The best include space for battery chargers and tackle so all your gear is stored neatly and ready to go.
  • Features: Fish finders use sonar to find fish, but some have additional features that make them more valuable. Navigation and mapping capabilities greatly add to the fish-catching potential.
  • User Friendliness: Technology is great, but only if it is easy to use. Are the menus intuitive? Can a gloved finger manipulate the controls?

We started with the most popular and reputable brands. Then, we compared the latest, most advanced models looking for the best features at the lowest price. Since flashers and graphing fish finders usually include a special transducer, carry case, and battery, we compared complete packages for the easiest fish finder to take on the ice and use all day or night in any conditions. Finally, we looked for units with the best signal and display that also provide the most accurate and up-to-date images of fish and structure.

What to Look For in an Ice Fishing Fish Finder

Ice fishing anglers want the most advanced sonar and navigation available. Choices range from basic sounders to advanced flashers and digital graphing fish finders with GPS. To weed out the best ice fishing fish finder for you, consider how and where you will use the unit.

Flasher or Graphing Fish Finder

The first choice is between a flasher or graphing fish finder. A flasher uses a circular display with fish and structure appearing as colored lines. A graphing fish finder uses a square screen with fish appearing as blobs or arches and structure represented with a line at the bottom of the screen.

Many ice anglers value the real-time readout of a flasher. The flasher allows you to watch your lure and the fish as they appear below the hole. By adjusting the settings, you can determine the density of the bottom structure to identify rocks, mud, or vegetation. Flashers are also reliable in cold weather and are easier to power with a smaller battery. 

To gain respect among serious ice anglers, digital graphing fish finders have improved real-time response and durability. The best graphing fish finders for ice fishing have a large, clear display of fish and structure below the ice. Ice anglers now have access to side view, down view, and even live view sonar to see life-like, real-time images up to 200 feet away. The best graphing fish finders will include a GPS with detailed maps and charts, making it possible to find the best structure and safely navigate to the fishing grounds.

Transducer

Ice fishing anglers have a wide variety of transducers to meet their needs. The best flasher fish finders use a cone-shaped transducer that provides a detailed return to mark fish and bait and determine the type of structure. Using the transducer cable, the angler drops the transducer through the hole, and a float keeps the transducer puck just below the ice.

Digital graphing fish finders offer a variety of sonar options. Many fish finders for ice fishing use a special transducer with flasher, 2D, and dual beam CHIRP sonar. Upgrading to forward view, live view, side view, or 360 view sonar requires a more advanced transducer. The transducer is mounted on a pole to lower it below the ice. 

Battery

The biggest limit to an ice fishing fish finder is battery power. A larger, brighter display and more powerful transducer require more battery power. Anglers trying to keep ice fishing simple will value a small fish finder that runs on AAA batteries. More advanced ice fishing fish finders require a small lead acid or lithium-ion battery. 

Choosing a fish finder for ice fishing comes down to how many features you need, how much weight you can carry, and how much money you will spend. More features and more options add to the weight and the price. But no matter your requirements for price level and features, there is a great fish finder for ice fishing for you.

FAQs

Q: What is the best transducer for ice fishing?

The best transducer for ice fishing is just as important as the display. To accurately send and receive sonar signals, the best transducers take advantage of the latest technology. With the most advanced transducers, anglers can see video-like images of fish and structure directly below the hole, to the sides and in front. Live view sonar provides video-like imaging of the fish, structure, and the lure or bait. Or, you can use a broadband or dual-frequency transducer to capture the action on a flasher or graphic display.
 
Consider how the transducer will be deployed beneath the ice. A broadband or dual frequency transducer is dropped into the ice hole on the transducer cable with a float to keep the puck just below the ice. Live view or side view transducers are mounted to a pole and positioned below the ice. Then, the pole is rotated so the transducer can capture images in all directions. 

Q: Why is a flasher better for ice fishing?

The first fish finders were analog flashers using a circular dial with a spinning arm and LED light to display fish and structure. While these systems were not as easy to read as a modern LCD graphing fish finder, a flasher provides the most accurate image of fish below the transducer. Today, graphing fish finders have reduced the delay between receiving the sonar signal and displaying the information on the screen, but many ice fishing anglers still prefer the reliability and versatility of a flasher.
 
Flashers can be adjusted to provide detailed information about the fish and type of structure below the transducer. Experienced anglers can interpret the return signal to watch their lure and see how the fish react. Flashers are usually smaller and lighter and draw less power than a large digital display, so they are easier to carry and power with a battery.

Q: Can you use a regular fish finder for ice fishing?

Any fish finder can be used for ice fishing. The display unit on an advanced digital fish finder or LED flasher is basically the same for boaters and ice anglers. The big difference is the transducer. Ice fishing transducers are easier to lower below the ice for a clear image of the bottom and fish. Boaters need a streamlined transducer that is designed to send and receive signal while on the move. To get year-round use out of your fish finder, in the winter use the carry case and ice transducer. Then, on open water, switch the display unit to a bracket and transducer mounted in your boat. 

Q: What’s the difference between a flasher and a digital sonar unit?

The difference between these two types of units is how they display information on what’s beneath the surface. A flasher shows a simplified display of markings on a circular graph. Sonar can show a detailed picture of exactly what is under the surface. Sonar can also show detailed images of structure on the bottom.

Q: Does an ice fish finder need to be waterproof?

One can argue that no, an ice fishing finder does not need to be waterproof. However, it may be preferable considering the snow and slush that is present while ice fishing. It’s a little extra peace of mind if you don’t need to worry about the elements harming your expensive fish finder.  

What Is the Best Fish Finder for Ice Fishing?

Ice anglers have a wide variety of fish finders to meet their needs. From simple, less expensive models with a few features to advanced models with all the bells and whistles, there is a high-quality, powerful, and reliable fish finder for your type of ice fishing. We found the Humminbird Ice Helix 9 to be the ultimate fish finder for ice and boat. A huge screen, advanced side view, down view, and live view imaging as well as traditional 2D and CHIRP sonar offer more opportunities to find fish and structure. The full-function GPS and detailed navigation charts identify the best fishing spots and the safest route onto the ice. In the summer, the Helix 9 is just as capable on a boat. Simply transfer the nine-inch display to a bracket and transducer installed on the boat. With the Humminbird Ice Helix 9, there is no place for fish to hide.

Why Trust Us

For more than 125 years, Field & Stream has been providing readers with honest and authentic coverage of outdoor gear. Our writers and editors eat, sleep, and breathe the outdoors, and that passion comes through in our product reviews. You can count on F&S to keep you up to date on the best new gear. And when we write about a product—whether it’s a bass lure or a backpack—we cover the good and the bad, so you know exactly what to expect before you decide to make a purchase.



Read the full article here

Subscribe to our newsletter

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy