Your #1 source for blades and firearms news and updates…

  • Home
  • Knives
  • News
  • Hunting
  • Tactical
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
Subscribe
Font ResizerAa
Blade ShopperBlade Shopper
  • News
  • Knives
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Tactical
  • Hunting
  • Videos
Search
  • Home
  • Knives
  • News
  • Hunting
  • Tactical
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
banner
Create an Amazing Newspaper
Discover thousands of options, easy to customize layouts, one-click to import demo and much more.
Learn More

Stay Updated

Get the latest headlines, discounts for the military community, and guides to maximizing your benefits
Subscribe

Explore

  • Photo of The Day
  • Opinion
  • Today's Epaper
  • Trending News
  • Weekly Newsletter
  • Special Deals
Home » A Pennsylvania Hunter Had His “Buck of a Lifetime” Stolen. So Why Are People Blaming Him?

A Pennsylvania Hunter Had His “Buck of a Lifetime” Stolen. So Why Are People Blaming Him?

Adam Green By Adam Green December 15, 2025 5 Min Read
Share
A Pennsylvania Hunter Had His “Buck of a Lifetime” Stolen. So Why Are People Blaming Him?

Sign up for the Outdoor Life Newsletter

Get the hottest outdoor news—plus a free month of onX Hunt Elite.

Wildlife officials in Pennsylvania are still seeking information about a tagged buck that was stolen from a hunter in the Tuscarora State Forest on Dec. 5. The deer, which officials are calling a “lifetime” buck, had been shot, tagged, and then stashed near a pipeline on the public forest that Friday. When the hunter returned later with his group to retrieve the buck, it was gone.

Oddly enough, however, a number of outspoken social-media users have blamed the hunter for the theft, leading one official to come to the hunter’s defense.

The hunter whose buck was stolen described the 9-pointer to officials as a “small bodied mountain deer,” and he estimated its score in the 150- to 160-inch range. The hunter described the rack as “very dark almost black,” and said one of its G4’s had broken off completely — details that officials hope will make it easier to identify.

“Evidence at the scene suggests an individual entered the pipeline from the area of View Trail off of Wolf Road, dragged the deer to a parking spot along Wolf Road where the deer was loaded and removed,” state forest officials wrote in a Facebook post on Dec. 9. They said “the deer did not appear to be visible from the road,” as the hunters had stashed it at the base of a large tree approximately 200 yards from the nearest roadway. 

Even with these facts, however, several commenters who claim to be sportsmen have blamed the hunter for the loss of his buck, saying they never would have left a buck of that caliber in the woods unattended. Some questioned the veracity of the evidence shared in the post, including the buck’s size, as well as the intelligence and ethics of the group of hunters. Two common critiques were that the hunters shouldn’t have kept hunting after tagging and-field dressing the 9-pointer, and that any hunter in their right mind would have at least photographed the buck.  

All this social-media banter led State Forest Ranger Steven Shaffer to speak out Friday and clarify some of the misinformation being spread online. Speaking with CBS-21 News, Shaffer said the hunters were Amish and do not have cell phones or cars. This explains the lack of photographs, and why they stayed out hunting after stashing the 9-pointer in the woods.   

“They normally would pay a driver to drive them to the location, so, somebody would drive them in a pickup truck, drop them off, and they usually spend the day hunting,” Shaffer told the news outlet. “The person that they have hired to transport them will come in, pick them up, and then they will load the animals at the end of the day and take them back home.”

Read Next: Watch: A Landowner Stole My Buddy’s Public-Land Elk to Deter Us from ‘Hunting This Outfit’

Shaffer added that since they’d killed and tagged the buck legally, there was nothing wrong with leaving it there temporarily. It’s also legal in Pennsylvania for hunters to harvest multiple deer in the same day, as long as they have the proper tags.

“They didn’t do anything wrong in this case,” Shaffer said. “They’re actually a victim of this crime and we’re trying to solve it for them.”

Officials are now asking local hunters to check their trail cameras for any suspicious photographs, and to report any information they might have about the theft.

Read the full article here

Share This Article
Facebook X Copy Link Print
Previous Article Pueblo Resident Uses .22 Revolver to Shoot Intruder Armed With Knife Pueblo Resident Uses .22 Revolver to Shoot Intruder Armed With Knife
Next Article Chiappa Unveils the New Rhino 60DS L-Frame in .44 Magnum with Three Distinct Finishes Chiappa Unveils the New Rhino 60DS L-Frame in .44 Magnum with Three Distinct Finishes
Leave a Comment Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Wake up with our popular morning roundup of the day's top blades, firearms and survavial news and updates.

United Nations Says Epstein Files May Contain “Crimes Against Humanity”

February 18, 2026

BoatUS Foundation Accepting Applications for New Life Jacket Loaner Pilot Program  

February 18, 2026

Iowa Lawmakers Move to Limit Campus Authority Over Guns in Private Vehicles

February 18, 2026

ATF seizes 36K guns as Trump administration shifts focus from Biden priorities to cartels, street crime

February 18, 2026

Zelensky: I Don’t Have Time “For All This Sh*t!”

February 18, 2026

You Might Also Like

Make Your Lever-Action Rifle More Accurate with These Tips and Shooting Techniques

Make Your Lever-Action Rifle More Accurate with These Tips and Shooting Techniques

Hunting
The World of Leupold Optics With Bruce Pettet, President & CEO of Leupold & Stevens, Inc. on the “Hunting Matters with Joe Betar” Podcast

The World of Leupold Optics With Bruce Pettet, President & CEO of Leupold & Stevens, Inc. on the “Hunting Matters with Joe Betar” Podcast

Hunting
Shoot United to Host First-Time Shotgun Shooters at Oak Tree Gun Club

Shoot United to Host First-Time Shotgun Shooters at Oak Tree Gun Club

Hunting
NWTF Local Michigan Chapter Hosts Annual Inclusive JAKES Event

NWTF Local Michigan Chapter Hosts Annual Inclusive JAKES Event

Hunting

2025 © Blade Shopper. All rights reserved.

Helpful Links

  • News
  • Knives
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Tactical
  • Hunting
  • Videos

Resources

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Popuplar

16 Types of Military Helicopters Used By The US Military
Bournemouth Air Festival: The UK’s Largest Air Festival
United Nations Says Epstein Files May Contain “Crimes Against Humanity”
We provide daily defense news, benefits information, veteran employment resources, spouse and family resources.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?