Benelli M2, M2-G1 and M4 Go Head-to-Head in New Testing
Benelli's lineup has three real answers to "which shotgun should I buy," and GunsAmerica just put the classic inertia-driven M2, the new gas-operated M2-G1, and the military-proven M4 through the same test to see how they actually stack up.
Snapshot
GunsAmerica ran all three Benelli shotguns through several hundred rounds and reported zero malfunctions across the board. The M2-G1, a newer rear-piston gas gun, posted the fastest split times in testing, while the outlet frames the choice as a tradeoff between the M4's combat pedigree, the M2-G1's speed and lower price, and the classic M2's light weight and simple upkeep.
Key points
- Action types differ: the classic M2 runs Benelli's inertia system, while both the M2-G1 and M4 rely on gas operation, according to GunsAmerica.
- M4 has the résumé: GunsAmerica notes the M4 carries the strongest service history and military credentials of the three.
- M2-G1 wins on speed and price: testing found the M2-G1 delivered the quickest split times and costs substantially less than the M4 EXT, per the outlet.
- No malfunctions reported: all three ran clean over several hundred rounds in GunsAmerica's testing.
- Light loads are a shared weak spot: none of the three models reliably cycled very light target loads under 1,000 fps, GunsAmerica found.
Quick take
For buyers cross-shopping these three, GunsAmerica's testing suggests the decision comes down to priorities rather than one clear winner: track record favors the M4, speed and value favor the M2-G1, and weight and low-maintenance running favor the classic M2. Ammo compatibility matters across the board, since none of them is built around the lightest target loads.
Read the full story: gunsamerica.com